Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Matt Cardin's avatar

Love this, Amanda. Thank you for your candidness and vulnerability in sharing it. The mystery of our personal experience, which demonstrates all that autonomy and otherness or alienness that you're noting within what we usually consider to be our own mental and emotional processes -- within "ourselves" -- is all-enveloping. It blurs the boundaries of what we mean by "I" and "me" when we really begin to attend to these things, whether in our writing or in everyday life.

Expand full comment
Kelila's avatar

Thank you for sharing this. It resonates on some level. When writing fiction I’ve always felt I was channeling. Much as you say here, the characters tell me their names and interact how they choose with the world and each other, I just get out of the way and transcribe it.

In my case, though, too many times my “fictional” story has turned out to be a detailed account of something that happened to a friend who hadn’t told me the story yet or, in one memorable instance, something that came true for me years after I wrote it and forgot about it: names, places, and all. If you had asked me before this happened if I believed in prophecy, I probably would have said no. And yet I’ve had these experiences. On one hand, it makes it much easier to acknowledge time and space as a construct. But on the other, it seems like deeply personal details to be putting out into the world, when I’m not even sure if it’s my story to share. So… I don’t publish most of the “fiction” I write these days. But I love reading about others with a similar relationship to their writing.

Expand full comment
10 more comments...

No posts